Open Source β€’ Apache 2.0 License

Cryptographic Accountability for Social Protection

A zero-knowledge proof architecture enabling governments to demonstrate program integrity without exposing individual beneficiary data.

Verify everything. Expose nothing.
4
Architectural Layers
10
Constituent Innovations
7
Evaluation Protocols
4
Implementation Tiers

The Accountability-Privacy Paradox

Social protection systems face a fundamental tension: accountability requires transparency, yet transparency can compromise beneficiary privacy and dignity.

πŸ”

Surveillance Risk

Traditional audit mechanisms require access to individual records, creating comprehensive surveillance capabilities that can be misused for population monitoring and political targeting.

βš–οΈ

Weak Legal Guarantees

Data protection regulations operate through legal constraints rather than technical guaranteesβ€”they can be weakened, circumvented, or ignored by future administrations.

πŸ”“

Infrastructure Gap

Existing digital public infrastructure platforms prioritize operational efficiency over privacy-preserving accountability, leaving a critical gap in governance architecture.

Four-Layer Architecture

DignityProof implements a comprehensive cryptographic accountability architecture through four integrated layers, each addressing specific requirements while maintaining privacy guarantees.

Figure 1: DignityProof Four-Layer Architecture

Private Domain

(Personal data under legal jurisdiction)

Layer 1: Data Management
(Privacy-First Information Handling)
Dual-Rail ZK
STARK + PLONK
Merkle-Sum
Aggregate Verify
Privacy ID
Deduplication
Layer 2: Proof Generation
(Human-Preserving Verification)
Human Appeals
2-of-3 Panel Override
Oracle Governance
N-of-M Attestation
Layer 3: Governance
(Institutional Accountability)
Procurement
OCDS+EPCIS
AEM
Exclusion Monitor
Evaluation
Pre-registration
Commitment
generation
Proof
attestation
Evidence
packaging

Public Domain

(Cryptographic commitments and proofs only)

Commitments

  • Hash values
  • Merkle roots
  • Zero data exposure

ZK Proofs

  • Validity attestations
  • Appeal records
  • Oracle signatures

Audit Evidence

  • Compliance proofs
  • AEM alerts
  • Research packages
External Verifiers
Auditors

Independent verification

Researchers

Impact evaluation

Civil Society

Public oversight

Regulators

Compliance check

Key Principle

Verify everything
Expose nothing

Layer 4: SDK (Implementation Tools)
Proof-of-Impact SDK Kill-Switch Governance Evidence Bundles Verifier Tools

Ten Constituent Innovations

1 DATA MANAGEMENT β€” Privacy-First Information Handling
1 Dual-Rail Zero-Knowledge Stack
STARK/IPA for security rail (post-quantum)
PLONK for performance rail (real-time)
Separates security from speed requirements
2 Merkle-Sum Commitment
Verifies aggregate totals match individual entries
Without revealing any individual record
Enables auditing of sums without data access
3 Privacy-Preserving Identity
Cryptographic binding without central database
Non-coercive deduplication mechanism
Prevents duplicates without surveillance
2 PROOF GENERATION β€” Human-Preserving Verification
4 Human Appeals Integration
2-of-3 panel structure for exception handling
Policy-bounded override with audit trail
Preserves human judgment within constraints
5 Oracle Governance Framework
N-of-M committee attestation for external data
Full provenance logging for all inputs
Trustworthy external data integration
3 GOVERNANCE β€” Institutional Accountability
6 Procurement Integrity
OCDS + EPCIS integration
ZK stock reconciliation for supply chains
Verifiable procurement without commercial exposure
β˜… Key Innovation
7 Active Exclusion Monitoring
False-negative rate as primary KPI
LQAS sampling with mandatory triggers
Treats exclusion as failure, not error
8 Evaluation Governance
Mandatory pre-registration of analysis
Hash-chain locked specifications
Prevents p-hacking and spec searching
4 SDK β€” Implementation and Safety Tools
9 Proof-of-Impact SDK
Evidence bundling for regulatory submission
Verifier tools + replication packages
Enables third-party validation
10 Kill-Switch Governance
Configurable anomaly triggers
Mandatory review before restart
Safety-first deployment model
Innovation Summary by Function
1-3 Enable verification without exposing personal data (cryptographic foundation)
4-5 Preserve human judgment within cryptographic constraints (accountability with flexibility)
6-8 Govern procurement, inclusion monitoring, and evaluation integrity (institutional trust)
9-10 Provide implementation tools and safety mechanisms (operational readiness)

Key Innovation

AEM (#7)
Exclusion = Failure

Platform Comparison

DignityProof provides cryptographic accountability capabilities that complement rather than compete with existing digital public infrastructure platforms.

Feature DignityProof Building Blocks MOSIP GovStack India Stack
Zero-knowledge proofs Full None None None None
Privacy-preserving audit Yes No No No No
Active exclusion monitoring Yes No No No No
Open source Yes No Yes Yes Partial
Human appeals integration Yes No No No No
Post-quantum ready Yes No No No No
Kill-switch governance Yes No No No No

Four-Tier Implementation Model

A progressive implementation pathway enabling adoption across varying institutional capacities, from basic audit trails to full zero-knowledge verification.

Tier 1

Basic Audit

Hash-chain audit trails with manual verification processes. Minimal technical requirements.

Tier 2

Commitment Layer

Merkle-sum commitments enabling aggregate verification without individual data access.

Tier 3

Selective ZK

Zero-knowledge proofs for high-risk operations with traditional audit for routine processes.

Tier 4

Full ZK

Complete zero-knowledge verification across all program operations with full AEM integration.

Resources & Documentation

πŸ“„

Technical Documentation

Complete architecture specification, API documentation, and implementation guides available on Zenodo.

View on Zenodo β†’
πŸ’»

Code Ocean Capsule

Reproducible computational environment demonstrating all framework components with executable examples.

Run on Code Ocean β†’
πŸ“§

Contact & Collaboration

Interested in implementing DignityProof or contributing to the project? Get in touch with the research team.

mohamed@dignityproof.org β†’

Ready to Transform Social Protection?

Join the movement toward privacy-preserving accountability. DignityProof is open source and ready for implementation.